by Guest » March 27, 2014, 12:58 pm
What must be remembered about this movie is that it is entertainment, not a documentary about sailing on lakeboats. I once read an article in the early 1980s written by an author of a highly-praised book about aerial warfare over Vietnam. Although this book sold very good on its accuracy, when his agent presented it to movie studios he was told that it was not entertaining enough. The prospective producers gave the author a list of changes they demanded before considering the project. As this would have changed the entire meaning of the story (I believe they wanted a romantic element between the primary pilot character and an North Vietnamese spy wanting the defect) the author decided to pass on continuing the project. The bottom line is that movies are entertainment (regardless if they are based on real events) and as such are subject to artistic license to improve ticket sales. Unfortunately, even some documentaries I have seen lately seem to be walking a fine line between education and entertainment, thus brining into question their historical. If you really want to know what life is like aboard lake freighters, there are several good books on the market written by sailors and ex-sailors. If on the other hand, you just want to watch a movie involving lake sailors than maybe the movie Lakeboat is for you. Regardless both have their place.
What must be remembered about this movie is that it is entertainment, not a documentary about sailing on lakeboats. I once read an article in the early 1980s written by an author of a highly-praised book about aerial warfare over Vietnam. Although this book sold very good on its accuracy, when his agent presented it to movie studios he was told that it was not entertaining enough. The prospective producers gave the author a list of changes they demanded before considering the project. As this would have changed the entire meaning of the story (I believe they wanted a romantic element between the primary pilot character and an North Vietnamese spy wanting the defect) the author decided to pass on continuing the project. The bottom line is that movies are entertainment (regardless if they are based on real events) and as such are subject to artistic license to improve ticket sales. Unfortunately, even some documentaries I have seen lately seem to be walking a fine line between education and entertainment, thus brining into question their historical. If you really want to know what life is like aboard lake freighters, there are several good books on the market written by sailors and ex-sailors. If on the other hand, you just want to watch a movie involving lake sailors than maybe the movie Lakeboat is for you. Regardless both have their place.